Looking Beyond the Signature Hardware 416305 Erica 57" Cast? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The signature hardware 416305 erica 57 cast alternatives list explores options for buyers who find this classic clawfoot tub appealing but need different specifications. This model offers a durable cast iron build and a compact 57-inch length that suits smaller bathrooms. It also provides a reversible drain and a strong warranty. However, some users may require more soaking depth, a wider basin, or a different foot finish. Others might prefer a longer tub for full-body immersion or a lighter unit for easier installation. These alternatives were chosen because their specs overlap with the original, ensuring they share core qualities like material and style.
The following 6 selections include other Signature Hardware models and one vintage option. Each entry matches the Erica tub’s classic aesthetic while varying in dimensions, weight, and color choices. You can compare lengths from 57 to 72 inches and widths from 17.7 to 30.5 inches. Weight ranges from 325 to 575 pounds, affecting floor support needs. Foot colors include polished nickel, chrome, bronze, and white. This guide helps you match the right tub to your bathroom’s size and your personal soaking preferences without compromising on traditional design.
Our top pick: Signature Hardware Erica 57" Clawfoot Tub.
How the alternatives differ from Erica
Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron
The Signature Hardware Lena 72-inch model is significantly larger than the Erica 57-inch tub. It measures 72 inches long compared to 57 inches, offering more soaking space for taller users. The width is also greater at 30.5 inches versus 23.8 inches. This extra room comes with a weight increase to 434 pounds, requiring a stronger floor structure than the 275-pound Erica. If you have a spacious bathroom and prioritize deep soaking over a compact footprint, this longer, wider cast iron tub is the better choice. It maintains the classic clawfoot style but demands more installation support.
Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron
The Signature Hardware Lena 59-inch tub is slightly longer than the 57-inch Erica but much narrower. Its width is only 17.7 inches, compared to the Erica’s 23.8 inches. This slim profile makes it ideal for very tight spaces where width is a constraint. However, the narrower basin may feel less comfortable for some bathers. The weight is 356 pounds, which is heavier than the Erica’s 275 pounds due to the cast iron construction. Choose this model if you need a classic clawfoot look but have limited bathroom width. It sacrifices soaking width for a smaller overall footprint.
Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Clawfoot
The Signature Hardware Lena 67-inch cast iron tub offers a middle ground in length between the 57-inch Erica and the 72-inch models. It measures 67 inches long and 27.9 inches wide. This width is wider than the Erica’s 23.8 inches, providing more shoulder room. The weight is 390 pounds, significantly heavier than the 275-pound Erica, so floor reinforcement is likely needed. It retains the classic clawfoot design and durable cast iron build. Select this option if you want more length and width than the Erica but do not need the maximum size of the 72-inch models. It suits bathrooms with ample space and strong flooring.
Signature Hardware Erica 57" Cast Iron Tub
The Signature Hardware Erica 57-inch tub in white with white feet shares the same dimensions as the original but differs in appearance and weight. It measures 57 inches long, 23.8 inches wide, and 30 inches high, matching the original specs. However, it weighs 325 pounds, which is 50 pounds heavier than the original 275-pound model. The color scheme uses white feet instead of polished nickel. This version is suitable if you prefer a monochromatic white aesthetic for your bathroom decor. The extra weight requires careful consideration of floor support during installation. It offers the same classic clawfoot style with a different visual finish.
Vintage Tub Charlotte 67" Cast Iron
The Vintage Tub Charlotte 67-inch cast iron tub is much larger and heavier than the 57-inch Erica. It measures 66.5 inches long and 30.1 inches wide, offering substantial soaking space. The weight is 575 pounds, far exceeding the Erica’s 275 pounds, necessitating robust floor support. This slipper-style design provides a deeper end for reclining. It features chrome fixtures and white feet, differing from the Erica’s polished nickel feet. Choose this model if you have a large bathroom and want a premium, classic clawfoot experience. It sacrifices compactness for maximum soaking comfort and traditional styling. The significant weight increase is the main trade-off for its size.
Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Tub
The Signature Hardware Lena 72-inch cast iron tub in slate blue is a long, narrow option compared to the Erica 57-inch tub. It measures 72 inches long but only 18.8 inches wide, which is narrower than the Erica’s 23.8 inches. The weight is 411 pounds, requiring strong floor support unlike the 275-pound Erica. The slate blue color with oil-rubbed bronze feet offers a distinct alternative to the Erica’s white and polished nickel look. This model suits buyers who prioritize length and durability over width. It is ideal for classic clawfoot settings where a bold color choice is desired. The narrow width may limit comfort for wider bathers.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Signature Hardware Erica 57" Clawfoot Tub
Best for: Classic clawfoot style and durability
- Type
- Clawfoot soaking tub
- Material
- Cast iron
- Length
- 57 inches
- Drain Location
- Reversible
- Mount Type
- clawfoot and free standing
- Dimensions
- 57 × 23.8 × 30 inches
View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Erica 57" Clawfoot Tub Affiliate link
The Signature Hardware Erica 57" is a cast iron clawfoot soaking tub measuring 57 inches long, 23.8 inches wide, and 30 inches high. It weighs 275 pounds and features a reversible drain. You get a classic white finish with polished nickel feet. This model suits those who want a durable, freestanding tub with a traditional aesthetic and a 25-year limited warranty.
Pros
- Cast iron construction for durability
- Reversible drain placement
- 25-year limited warranty
- Clawfoot and free-standing installation
Cons
- 57-inch length is shorter than 59-inch and 72-inch alternatives
- 275-pound weight requires strong floor support
- Standard 30-inch height may not suit taller users
Good fit if
- You prefer a classic clawfoot design
- You need a reversible drain option
- You want a 25-year warranty
Skip if
- You need a tub longer than 57 inches
- You cannot support a 275-pound weight
- You prefer a modern freestanding shape
Verdict: Signature Hardware Erica 57" Cast Iron Tub offers a compact, durable soaking option for smaller bathrooms. It fits buyers who prioritize classic styling and long-term warranty coverage over maximum length.
Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron
Best for: spacious bathrooms needing deep soaking
- Type
- Clawfoot
- Material
- Cast iron
- Length
- 72 inches
- Drain Location
- Center
- Dimensions
- 72 × 30.5 × 28.5 inches
- Weight
- 434 pounds
View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Affiliate link
This 72-inch clawfoot tub offers substantial soaking space with a center drain and pre-drilled overflow hole. Its cast iron body weighs 434 pounds, ensuring stability and heat retention. The white finish pairs with brushed nickel feet for a classic look. It suits larger bathrooms where you need a deep, durable tub for extended relaxation.
Pros
- 72-inch length provides ample soaking space
- 434-pound cast iron construction for durability
- Center drain placement for efficient water removal
- 25-year limited warranty coverage
Cons
- Requires a large floor area due to 72-inch length
- Heavy weight demands a reinforced floor structure
- Standard height may be less comfortable for some users
Good fit if
- You have a spacious bathroom layout
- You prefer deep soaking experiences
- You want a durable, long-lasting material
Skip if
- You have limited floor space
- You cannot support heavy loads
- You prefer a compact soaking option
Verdict: Signature Hardware 72 Inch Cast Iron Soaking Tub is ideal for buyers with ample bathroom space who prioritize deep soaking and long-term durability over compactness.
Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron
Best for: compact bathrooms needing a classic clawfoot style
- Type
- Clawfoot soaking tub
- Material
- Cast iron
- Length
- 59 inches
- Drain Location
- Center
- Mount Type
- clawfoot and free standing
- Dimensions
- 59 × 17.7 × 26.8 inches
View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron Affiliate link
The Signature Hardware Lena 59" is a clawfoot soaking tub made from cast iron. It measures 59 inches long, 17.7 inches wide, and 26.8 inches high. The tub weighs 356 pounds and features a center drain. It includes a pre-drilled overflow hole and tap deck. This model suits you if you want a classic freestanding design with durable construction.
Pros
- Cast iron construction for durability
- 59-inch length for soaking
- Center drain placement
- 25-year limited warranty
- Available in multiple foot finishes
Cons
- Smaller 59-inch length than other options
- Heavier at 356 pounds
- Standard 26.8-inch height limits deep soaking
Good fit if
- You need a 59-inch tub for smaller bathrooms
- You prefer a center drain layout
- You want a classic clawfoot style
Skip if
- You require a longer soaking tub
- You need a slipper design
- You want a lighter installation weight
Verdict: Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron Tub fits buyers who prioritize a compact footprint and classic aesthetics over maximum soaking depth.
Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Clawfoot
Best for: long soaking in traditional clawfoot settings
- Type
- clawfoot
- Material
- cast iron
- Length
- 67 inches
- Mount Type
- free standing
- Dimensions
- 67 × 27.9 × 27.9 inches
- Weight
- 390 pounds
View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Clawfoot Affiliate link
This Signature Hardware Lena tub is a 67-inch cast iron soaking tub with a clawfoot design. It measures 27.9 inches wide and high, weighing 390 pounds. The unit features a rolled rim and installs as a free-standing piece. It includes a 25-year limited warranty for residential use. You get a durable, heavy-duty option for those who want a classic clawfoot style with substantial build quality.
Pros
- 67-inch length provides ample soaking space
- Cast iron construction ensures long-term durability
- 390-pound weight offers stable, wobble-free installation
- 25-year limited residential warranty included
- Available in five different finish combinations
Cons
- Drain is not included in the package
- 390-pound weight requires reinforced floor support
- Standard clawfoot height may be less accessible
Good fit if
- You want a traditional clawfoot aesthetic
- You have a floor that supports heavy loads
- You prefer a longer soaking experience
Skip if
- You need the drain to be included
- You have limited floor load capacity
- You prefer a modern, low-profile design
Verdict: Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron is a heavy, durable choice for bathrooms that can support its 390-pound frame. It suits buyers seeking a classic, long-soaking clawfoot tub with a strong warranty. It is not suitable for those needing a complete kit or lightweight installation.
Signature Hardware Erica 57" Cast Iron Tub
Best for: traditional clawfoot bathroom aesthetics
- Type
- Clawfoot soaking tub
- Material
- Cast iron
- Length
- 57 inches
- Drain Location
- Left or right
- Dimensions
- 57 × 23.8 × 30 inches
- Weight
- 325 pounds
View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Erica 57" Cast Iron Tub Affiliate link
This 57-inch clawfoot soaking tub is built from cast iron, offering a classic aesthetic and durable construction. It measures 57 inches long, 23.8 inches wide, and 30 inches high. The tub weighs 325 pounds, indicating a substantial build. It features a pre-drilled overflow hole and allows for left or right drain placement. You can choose from six foot finish options to match your bathroom decor.
Pros
- 57-inch length provides ample soaking space
- Cast iron material ensures long-term durability
- Flexible left or right drain location
- Six foot finish options available
- Pre-drilled overflow hole included
Cons
- Weighs 325 pounds, requiring strong floor support
- Narrow 23.8-inch width limits lateral comfort
- No built-in jets or water circulation system
Good fit if
- You want a classic clawfoot design
- You have a bathroom floor rated for heavy loads
- You need flexible drain placement
Skip if
- You need a jetted or whirlpool experience
- You have limited floor space or weight capacity
- You prefer a modern, low-profile soaking tub
Verdict: Signature Hardware Erica 57" Cast Iron Tub is a heavy, classic soaking tub for bathrooms that can support its 325-pound weight. It suits those prioritizing traditional clawfoot style and durable cast iron construction over modern hydrotherapy features.
Vintage Tub Charlotte 67" Cast Iron
Best for: large bathrooms needing classic clawfoot style
- Type
- clawfoot
- Material
- cast iron
- Length
- 66.5 inches
- Dimensions
- 66.5 × 30.1 × 30 inches
- Weight
- 575 pounds
View on Amazon: Vintage Tub Charlotte 67" Cast Iron Affiliate link
The Vintage Tub Charlotte is a 67-inch cast iron slipper clawfoot tub. It measures 66.5 inches long and 30.1 inches wide. The unit weighs 575 pounds, ensuring stability. It features a white finish with white feet and chrome fixtures. This large capacity tub suits bathrooms with ample floor space. The slipper design offers ergonomic support for soaking.
Pros
- 67-inch length provides ample soaking space
- Cast iron construction ensures heat retention
- 575-pound weight adds stability
- Slipper design offers ergonomic support
Cons
- 575-pound weight requires reinforced flooring
- 66.5-inch length needs large bathroom footprint
- Slipper shape may not suit all preferences
Good fit if
- You have a large bathroom with reinforced flooring
- You want a classic clawfoot style with chrome fixtures
- You prefer a slipper design for ergonomic soaking
Skip if
- You have limited floor space in your bathroom
- You cannot support a 575-pound tub
- You prefer a modern minimalist aesthetic
Verdict: Vintage Tub Charlotte 67" Cast Iron fits large bathrooms needing a stable, heat-retaining soak. Its slipper design and chrome fixtures suit classic decor.
Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Tub
Best for: Deep soaking in classic clawfoot designs
- Type
- Clawfoot soaking tub
- Material
- Cast iron
- Length
- 72 inches
- Drain Location
- Center
- Mount Type
- clawfoot and free standing
- Dimensions
- 72 × 18.8 × 28.5 inches
View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Tub Affiliate link
This 72-inch clawfoot soaking tub offers deep immersion with a center drain. The cast iron body weighs 411 pounds, providing stability and heat retention. You get a classic look with a 25-year limited warranty. The slate blue finish pairs with oil-rubbed bronze feet. It fits free-standing spaces well. The width is 18.8 inches and height is 28.5 inches.
Pros
- 72-inch length for extended soaking
- Heavy cast iron construction at 411 pounds
- 25-year limited warranty coverage
- Center drain placement
Cons
- 411-pound weight requires strong floor support
- 18.8-inch width is narrow for some users
- No pre-drilled faucet holes included
Good fit if
- You need a long tub for full-body immersion
- You want a classic clawfoot aesthetic
- You have a reinforced floor for heavy fixtures
Skip if
- You require pre-drilled faucet holes
- You have a narrow bathroom with limited width
- You cannot support a 411-pound load
Verdict: Signature Hardware 72" Lena Cast Iron Tub is a heavy-duty option for those prioritizing length and durability over width. It suits bathrooms with strong floors and classic decor preferences.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Signature Hardware Erica 57" Clawfoot Tub | Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron | Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron | Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Clawfoot | Signature Hardware Erica 57" Cast Iron Tub | Vintage Tub Charlotte 67" Cast Iron | Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Tub |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Clawfoot soaking tub | Clawfoot | Clawfoot soaking tub | clawfoot | Clawfoot soaking tub | clawfoot | Clawfoot soaking tub |
| Material | Cast iron | Cast iron | Cast iron | cast iron | Cast iron | cast iron | Cast iron |
| Length | 57 inches | 72 inches | 59 inches | 67 inches | 57 inches | 66.5 inches | 72 inches |
| Drain Location | Reversible | Center | Center | not stated | Left or right | not stated | Center |
| Mount Type | clawfoot and free standing | not stated | clawfoot and free standing | free standing | not stated | not stated | clawfoot and free standing |
| Dimensions | 57 × 23.8 × 30 inches | 72 × 30.5 × 28.5 inches | 59 × 17.7 × 26.8 inches | 67 × 27.9 × 27.9 inches | 57 × 23.8 × 30 inches | 66.5 × 30.1 × 30 inches | 72 × 18.8 × 28.5 inches |
| Weight | 275 pounds | 434 pounds | 356 pounds | 390 pounds | 325 pounds | 575 pounds | 411 pounds |
| Color | White / Polished Nickel Feet | White / Brushed Nickel Feet | White / Chrome Feet | White / Chrome | White / White Feet | White / White Feet & Chrome Fixtures | Slate Blue / Oil Rubbed Bronze Feet |
| Model | 903343-57 | 917203-72-RR | 917203-59-RH | 946168-66-RR-NO | 903344-57-RR | not stated | 931047-72-RR |
| Size | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | 67 IN | not stated |
If you compare enamel coatings, our guide to le creuset enameled cast iron signature alternatives outlines related material specifications.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Signature Hardware Erica 57-inch tub made of cast iron?
Yes, the Signature Hardware Erica 57-inch tub is constructed from cast iron. This material provides significant durability and heat retention compared to lighter alternatives. The tub weighs between 275 and 325 pounds depending on the specific finish and feet configuration you select.
What are the exact dimensions of the Signature Hardware Erica 57-inch cast iron tub?
The tub measures 57 inches in length, 23.8 inches in width, and 30 inches in height. These compact dimensions make it suitable for smaller bathrooms while still offering a classic clawfoot aesthetic. The narrow width helps it fit into tighter spaces effectively.
How does the weight of the Erica 57-inch tub compare to larger models?
The Erica 57-inch tub weighs between 275 and 325 pounds. This is lighter than the 72-inch Lena models, which weigh between 390 and 434 pounds. The lighter weight makes installation slightly easier while still maintaining the structural integrity of cast iron.
Can I find the Signature Hardware Erica 57-inch tub with different foot colors?
Yes, you can choose between polished nickel feet or white feet. The polished nickel option offers a classic metallic look, while the white feet blend seamlessly with the tub body. Both options maintain the same durable cast iron construction and compact footprint.
Are there alternative Signature Hardware cast iron tubs with a 72-inch length?
Yes, the Signature Hardware Lena series offers a 72-inch length option. These models provide more soaking space for taller users. They are wider and heavier than the 57-inch Erica, requiring more floor space and stronger structural support in your bathroom.
Does the Signature Hardware Erica 57-inch tub include a slipper design?
No, the Erica 57-inch tub features a standard rectangular shape with clawfoot mounts. It does not have a raised end or slipper design. If you prefer a contoured shape for head support, you might consider the Vintage Tub Charlotte model instead.
What is the width difference between the Erica and Lena 72-inch tubs?
The Erica 57-inch tub is 23.8 inches wide. The Lena 72-inch tub is 30.5 inches wide in some configurations or 18.8 inches in others. The wider 30.5-inch version offers more lateral space, while the narrower version maintains a slimmer profile despite its length.
Is the Signature Hardware Erica 57-inch tub suitable for small bathrooms?
Yes, its 57-inch length and 23.8-inch width make it ideal for smaller bathrooms. The compact footprint allows for easier maneuvering during installation. It provides classic clawfoot styling without requiring the extensive floor space needed by larger 72-inch or 67-inch tub models.