6 Best Alternatives to the Signature Hardware 915546-61-RH-ND Arabella 61" Cast (2026)

How alternatives compare to Arabella

Signature Hardware Erica 57" Cast Iron Tub

The Signature Hardware Erica 57" Cast Iron Tub is a compact alternative for smaller bathrooms. It measures 57 inches long and 23.8 inches wide, making it significantly narrower than the 61-inch Arabella. At 325 pounds, it is slightly heavier than the 300-pound Arabella, despite its smaller footprint. The Erica offers a classic clawfoot design with white porcelain and white feet. This model sacrifices the double-slipper capacity of the Arabella for a tighter fit. It is a practical choice if your bathroom layout cannot accommodate a 61-inch tub. The reduced width may limit comfort for larger users, but it retains the durable cast iron construction and heat retention properties you expect from this brand.

Vintage Tub Charlotte 67" Cast Iron

The Vintage Tub & Bath Charlotte 67" Cast Iron Tub provides a longer soaking experience. At 66.5 inches long, it exceeds the 61-inch length of the Arabella. This model weighs 575 pounds, which is nearly double the weight of the Arabella. You must ensure your floor can support this substantial load. The Charlotte features a slipper design with one raised end, differing from the double-slipper layout of the Arabella. It includes chrome fixtures and white feet, offering a slightly different aesthetic than the oil-rubbed bronze option. This tub is ideal if you prioritize extra length and deep soaking over the wider, side-by-side capacity of the Arabella. The increased weight and length require more space and structural support.

Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron

The Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Tub is the longest option in this comparison. It measures 72 inches in length, providing 11 more inches of soak space than the Arabella. This model weighs 434 pounds, making it heavier than the 300-pound Arabella. The width is 30.5 inches, slightly wider than the Arabella's 30-inch width. It features brushed nickel feet, offering a different finish choice. The Lena is designed for users who want maximum length for extended soaking sessions. It sacrifices the double-slipper symmetry of the Arabella for a longer, single-slipper profile. This tub is best for taller users or those who prefer a more elongated bathing experience. The additional weight requires careful consideration of floor load capacity.

Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron

The Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron Tub is a narrower alternative to the Arabella. It measures 59 inches long and only 17.7 inches wide, making it much slimmer than the 61-inch, 30-inch wide Arabella. At 356 pounds, it is heavier than the Arabella despite its smaller dimensions. This model is designed for small bathrooms where width is a constraint. It offers a single-slipper design, unlike the double-slipper Arabella. The chrome feet provide a modern look compared to the oil-rubbed bronze option. This tub is suitable if you need a deep soak in a tight space. You give up the ability to soak side-by-side but gain a tub that fits narrower layouts. The reduced width may feel cramped for larger users.

Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Clawfoot

The Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Clawfoot Tub offers a middle ground in length. At 67 inches long, it is longer than the Arabella but shorter than the 72-inch Lena. It weighs 390 pounds, heavier than the 300-pound Arabella. The width is 27.9 inches, slightly narrower than the Arabella's 30-inch width. This model features chrome feet, differing from the oil-rubbed bronze option. It is designed for traditional soaking with a single-slipper profile. This tub is ideal if you want more length than the Arabella but do not need the maximum 72-inch size. The narrower width may affect comfort for wider users. It retains the durable cast iron construction and heat retention properties of the Arabella, making it a solid choice for classic bathing.

Signature Hardware Erica 57" Clawfoot Tub

The Signature Hardware Erica 57" Clawfoot Tub is a lighter alternative to the Arabella. It measures 57 inches long and 23.8 inches wide, making it smaller in both dimensions. At 275 pounds, it is lighter than the 300-pound Arabella, which may simplify installation. This model features polished nickel feet, offering a different finish choice. It has a single-slipper design, unlike the double-slipper Arabella. This tub is suitable for smaller bathrooms where space is limited. You sacrifice the side-by-side soaking capacity of the Arabella for a more compact footprint. The Erica retains the classic clawfoot style and durable cast iron construction. It is a practical choice if you need a reliable, space-saving tub that still offers the benefits of cast iron heat retention.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Signature Hardware Arabella 61" Cast Iron Tub

Best for: Couples wanting double-slipper soaking

Type

Cast Iron Soaking Clawfoot Tub

Material

Cast Iron

Length

61 inches

Water Capacity

30 Gallons

Mount Type

Clawfoot

Dimensions

61 × 30 × 29 inches

View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Arabella 61" Cast Iron Tub

The Signature Hardware Arabella is a 61-inch cast iron soaking tub with a double-slipper design. It holds 30 gallons of water and measures 29 inches high. The white porcelain enamel resists scratches and retains heat well. You get a 7-inch rim tap deck for faucet placement. This model suits those who want a classic clawfoot style with ample soaking space.

Pros

• Double-slipper design allows reclining at either end
• Cast iron construction retains heat effectively
• 30-gallon water capacity for deep soaking
• Porcelain enamel surface is scratch-resistant
• 7-inch rim tap deck included

Cons

• Weighs 300 pounds, requiring reinforced flooring
• Standard 30-gallon capacity is smaller than some competitors
• No integrated jets or electronic controls

Good fit if

• You want a double-slipper tub for two people
• You prefer traditional clawfoot aesthetics
• You need a heat-retaining cast iron material

Skip if

• You have a floor that cannot support 300 pounds
• You want a smaller 57-inch or 59-inch footprint
• You require modern jetted or air-bath features

Verdict: Signature Hardware Arabella 61" Cast Iron Tub is a heavy, heat-retaining option for bathrooms that can support its 300-pound weight. It fits couples who want to soak side-by-side in a classic clawfoot design.

2 Best budget

Signature Hardware Erica 57" Cast Iron Tub

Best for: small bathroom clawfoot setups

Type

Clawfoot soaking tub

Material

Cast iron

Length

57 inches

Drain Location

Left or right

Dimensions

57 × 23.8 × 30 inches

Weight

325 pounds

View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Erica 57" Cast Iron Tub

The Erica is a 57-inch cast iron clawfoot soaking tub. It measures 23.8 inches wide and 30 inches high. The drain location is adjustable for left or right installation. You get a pre-drilled overflow hole for safety. This model suits smaller bathrooms where space is limited. The heavy cast iron construction ensures durability. It fits well if you want a classic look without a large footprint.

Pros

• 57-inch length saves floor space
• Adjustable left or right drain location
• Pre-drilled overflow hole included
• Durable cast iron construction

Cons

• Shorter 57-inch length limits soaking depth
• Narrow 23.8-inch width reduces comfort
• Heavy 325-pound weight complicates installation

Good fit if

• You need a tub that fits a compact bathroom layout
• You want a classic clawfoot style with a smaller footprint
• You prefer adjustable drain placement for plumbing flexibility

Skip if

• You require a deep soaking experience for tall bodies
• You need a wider basin for extra comfort
• You cannot support a 325-pound fixture in your bathroom

Verdict: Signature Hardware Erica 57" Cast Iron Tub fits small bathrooms well. It offers classic style and durable cast iron build for tight spaces.

3 Also great

Vintage Tub Charlotte 67" Cast Iron

Best for: Deep soaking in a traditional clawfoot design

Type

clawfoot

Material

cast iron

Length

66.5 inches

Dimensions

66.5 × 30.1 × 30 inches

Weight

575 pounds

View on Amazon: Vintage Tub Charlotte 67" Cast Iron

The Charlotte 67-inch slipper clawfoot tub offers deep soaking in a classic design. Constructed from cast iron with porcelain enamel, it retains heat well. At 66.5 inches long and 30.1 inches wide, it provides ample space. The package includes white feet and chrome fixtures. Its 575-pound weight ensures stability. This tub suits those seeking a traditional centerpiece for their bathroom.

Pros

• Cast iron construction with premium class A porcelain enamel for durability.
• 66.5-inch length and 30.1-inch width provide generous soaking space.
• Includes white feet and chrome fixtures in the package.
• 575-pound weight ensures a stable and solid installation.

Cons

• 575-pound weight requires a floor with sufficient structural support.
• Fixed 30-inch height may not suit users preferring a lower or higher tub.
• Standard chrome fixtures included; brushed nickel or other finishes require separate purchase.

Good fit if

• You want a heavy, durable cast iron tub that retains heat.
• You need a 67-inch slipper clawfoot design with included fixtures.
• You are installing the tub on a floor rated for heavy loads.

Skip if

• You need a lightweight tub that is easy to move or install.
• You prefer a modern acrylic material over traditional cast iron.
• You require a tub with a lower height than 30 inches.

Verdict: Vintage Tub & Bath Charlotte 67" Slipper Clawfoot is a solid choice for bathrooms needing a heavy, heat-retaining cast iron tub with included fixtures. It fits users prioritizing durability and classic styling over lightweight convenience.

4 Best premium

Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron

Best for: long soaking and classic clawfoot style

Type

Clawfoot

Material

Cast iron

Length

72 inches

Drain Location

Center

Dimensions

72 × 30.5 × 28.5 inches

Weight

434 pounds

View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron

This 72-inch cast iron soaking tub offers ample space for deep bathing. It features a classic clawfoot design with a center drain for easy installation. The tub weighs 434 pounds and stands 28.5 inches tall. It includes a pre-drilled overflow hole and comes with a 25-year limited warranty. You will find five foot color options to match your decor.

Pros

• 72-inch length provides generous soaking space
• Durable cast iron construction
• 25-year limited warranty coverage
• Center drain placement simplifies plumbing
• Five brushed nickel, black, brass, chrome, or bronze foot options

Cons

• Heavy 434-pound weight requires strong floor support
• Standard 28.5-inch height may not suit users preferring deeper soaking
• No built-in jets or massage features

Good fit if

• You need a 72-inch tub for extra legroom
• You want a classic clawfoot aesthetic
• You prefer a durable cast iron material

Skip if

• You have limited bathroom floor space
• You cannot support a 434-pound fixture
• You want a modern acrylic or fiberglass tub

Verdict: Signature Hardware Lena 72 Inch Clawfoot Tub fits bathrooms needing long soaking capacity. It suits those prioritizing traditional style and material durability over modern jet features.

5 Also great

Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron

Best for: Small bathrooms needing a deep soak

Type

Clawfoot soaking tub

Material

Cast iron

Length

59 inches

Drain Location

Center

Mount Type

clawfoot and free standing

Dimensions

59 × 17.7 × 26.8 inches

View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron

This 59-inch clawfoot soaking tub is built from cast iron for durability. It features a center drain and pre-drilled overflow hole. The tub stands 26.8 inches high and weighs 356 pounds. It offers a classic look with chrome feet. You will find five foot finish options. This size suits smaller bathrooms while still providing a deep soak.

Pros

• Cast iron construction ensures long-term durability
• 59-inch length fits tighter bathroom footprints
• Pre-drilled overflow hole and tap deck included
• Five foot finish options available
• 25-year limited warranty coverage

Cons

• 59-inch length is shorter than the 61-inch and 67-inch alternatives
• 356-pound weight requires a reinforced floor
• Center drain placement may limit faucet positioning flexibility

Good fit if

• You have a bathroom where a 59-inch footprint is the maximum available width
• You prefer a classic clawfoot design with a center drain
• You want a deep soaking tub that weighs less than the larger 72-inch models

Skip if

• You need a tub longer than 59 inches for a larger master bath
• You prefer a side drain location for specific plumbing layouts
• You cannot support a 356-pound cast iron tub on your floor

Verdict: Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron Tub is a practical choice for smaller bathrooms that still need a deep soak. It fits buyers who prioritize a classic clawfoot look and a manageable footprint over maximum length.

6 Also great

Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Clawfoot

Best for: Long, traditional soaking baths

Type

clawfoot

Material

cast iron

Length

67 inches

Mount Type

free standing

Dimensions

67 × 27.9 × 27.9 inches

Weight

390 pounds

View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Clawfoot

This 67-inch clawfoot tub offers a spacious soak in a free-standing design. The cast iron body weighs 390 pounds, providing stability and heat retention. You get a 25-year limited warranty for residential use. The rolled rim adds a classic touch. It is a solid choice for those who want a durable, traditional soaking experience without the complexity of modern electronics.

Pros

• 67-inch length provides ample soaking space
• Cast iron construction ensures durability and heat retention
• 25-year limited residential warranty included
• Free-standing clawfoot design fits various layouts
• Rolled rim adds a classic aesthetic

Cons

• Weighs 390 pounds, requiring strong floor support
• Drain is not included with the tub
• No built-in jets or modern features

Good fit if

• You need a long tub for full-body immersion
• You want a durable, heavy-duty material
• You prefer a traditional clawfoot style

Skip if

• You have a floor that cannot support heavy weight
• You want a complete package with a drain
• You prefer a smaller footprint under 60 inches

Verdict: Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Tub is a robust option for buyers seeking a long, traditional soaking experience. It suits those who prioritize material durability and warranty coverage over modern conveniences.

7 Also great

Signature Hardware Erica 57" Clawfoot Tub

Best for: smaller bathrooms needing durable classic style

Type

Clawfoot soaking tub

Material

Cast iron

Length

57 inches

Drain Location

Reversible

Mount Type

clawfoot and free standing

Dimensions

57 × 23.8 × 30 inches

View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Erica 57" Clawfoot Tub

This 57-inch cast iron soaking tub features a classic clawfoot design with reversible drain placement. Weighing 275 pounds, it offers a stable, free-standing installation. The white enamel with polished nickel feet suits traditional bathrooms. It includes a pre-drilled overflow hole and is backed by a 25-year limited warranty. This model fits smaller alcoves or rooms where a 61-inch tub would not fit.

Pros

• 57-inch length fits tighter spaces
• Reversible drain placement for flexible plumbing
• 275-pound cast iron construction for durability
• 25-year limited warranty coverage

Cons

• Shorter 57-inch length than the 61-inch Signature Hardware Arabella
• Heavier 275-pound build requires strong floor support
• Standard clawfoot height limits deep soaking compared to slipper styles

Good fit if

• You need a soaking tub that fits in a narrower bathroom
• You prefer a classic clawfoot aesthetic with polished nickel accents
• You want a durable cast iron tub with a long warranty

Skip if

• You require a 61-inch or longer soaking tub
• You cannot support a 275-pound heavy tub
• You prefer a lighter acrylic material for easier installation

Verdict: Signature Hardware Erica 57" Clawfoot Soaking Tub is a solid choice for smaller bathrooms needing durable, classic style. It suits buyers who prioritize weight stability and warranty length over maximum soaking depth.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• victrola century signature alternatives
• logitech signature slim k950 wireless alternatives