Signature Hardware vs Vintage Tub & Bath Bathtubs: Which Brand Fits You?
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are comparing signature hardware vs vintage tub bath bathtub options for a classic clawfoot setup. Both brands offer 72-inch tubs designed for clawfoot installation, giving you a timeless look. The main difference lies in the material and weight. Signature Hardware uses heavy cast iron for durability, while Vintage Tub & Bath offers a lighter acrylic shell. This affects how you handle the tub and the support it needs.
Key differences
| Aspect | Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron | Vintage Tub & Bath 72" Acrylic Clawfoot |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Cast iron | Acrylic |
| Weight | 434 pounds | 79 pounds |
| Type | Clawfoot | Double Slipper Clawfoot |
| Drain Location | Center | not listed |
| Height | 28.5 inches | 32 inches |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron if
- You want a tub with a 25-year limited warranty for long-term peace of mind.
- You prefer the classic feel and heat retention of cast iron construction.
- You need a center drain placement for your plumbing layout.
Choose Vintage Tub & Bath 72" Acrylic Clawfoot if
- You need a lightweight tub that simplifies installation and floor support.
- You want a higher water capacity due to the taller 32-inch height.
- You prefer a non-porous acrylic surface that resists mold and mildew.
Verdict: Choose Signature Hardware if you prioritize durability, heat retention, and a long warranty. Pick Vintage Tub & Bath if you need easier installation due to low weight and want a taller soak. Both provide a 72-inch clawfoot style, so your choice depends on material preference and structural needs.
Clawfoot Tub Comparison Guide
Material durability
Signature Hardware uses cast iron for its Lena model, a material known for extreme durability and heat retention. This heavy-duty construction ensures the tub will last for decades without cracking or chipping. In contrast, Vintage Tub & Bath offers an acrylic option. Acrylic is lighter and easier to handle, but it is not as inherently tough as cast iron. If you prioritize a surface that resists impact and retains heat longer, the cast iron construction of the Signature Hardware tub provides a clear advantage in longevity and structural integrity compared to the more vulnerable acrylic shell.
Installation weight
The weight difference between these two tubs is significant and impacts your installation process. The Signature Hardware cast iron tub weighs 434 pounds, requiring substantial floor support and professional handling during placement. Vintage Tub & Bath’s acrylic model weighs only 79 pounds. This lightweight construction simplifies installation significantly, as it is easier to move into position and places less stress on your floor structure. If you are concerned about floor load limits or want a simpler setup, the Vintage Tub & Bath option is much easier to manage physically.
Soaking comfort
Both tubs are 72 inches long, but their interior shapes differ. The Signature Hardware model is a standard clawfoot soaking tub. Vintage Tub & Bath offers a double slipper design. A double slipper tub typically features raised ends on both sides, allowing you to rest your head and feet comfortably while submerged. This ergonomic shape is designed specifically for relaxation. If you want a tub that contours to your body for a more luxurious soak, the double slipper design of the Vintage Tub & Bath model offers a practical advantage over the standard soaking shape.
Drain placement
Plumbing compatibility is crucial for a smooth installation. The Signature Hardware Lena tub features a center drain placement. This is a traditional configuration that works well with standard floor drains. The product data for the Vintage Tub & Bath model does not specify the drain location. You must verify this detail before purchasing to ensure it matches your existing plumbing layout. If you have a center drain setup, the Signature Hardware tub is the safer choice without requiring additional verification or plumbing modifications.
Finish maintenance
Keeping your tub clean affects daily use. Vintage Tub & Bath highlights a high-gloss, non-porous acrylic surface that resists mold, mildew, and staining. This finish is easy to wipe down and maintains its brilliance over time without dulling. Signature Hardware lists a 25-year limited warranty but does not detail specific surface resistance properties in the provided data. For a finish that actively resists buildup and requires minimal effort to keep looking new, the non-porous acrylic surface of the Vintage Tub & Bath tub offers a practical benefit for everyday cleaning.
Which bathtub suits your needs best
You want maximum durability and heat retention
The Signature Hardware Lena features cast iron construction, which is known for extreme durability and superior heat retention. Weighing 434 pounds, this tub stays warm longer during soaks. It includes a 25-year limited warranty, providing long-term peace of mind. The heavy material ensures it will last for decades without cracking or chipping, making it a permanent fixture for serious soaking enthusiasts.
You prefer lightweight installation and easy cleaning
The Vintage Tub & Bath model uses high-gloss acrylic, weighing only 79 pounds. This lightweight construction simplifies installation significantly. The non-porous surface resists mold and mildew, making it easy to clean. The finish is stain-resistant and durable against dulling or scratching. Adjustable levelers on the lion paw feet help stabilize the tub, ensuring a secure fit without the burden of heavy materials.
You need precise leveling and adjustable feet
Vintage Tub & Bath includes feet with adjustable levelers to stabilize the bathtub on uneven floors. This feature simplifies installation and ensures the tub remains secure. The acrylic body is lighter, reducing structural stress on floor joists. The non-porous surface prevents mold buildup, keeping the tub hygienic with minimal effort. This setup is ideal for older homes where leveling might be challenging.
The products compared
Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron
Best for: Classic bathrooms needing deep soaking
- Type
- Clawfoot
- Material
- Cast iron
- Length
- 72 inches
- Drain Location
- Center
- Dimensions
- 72 × 30.5 × 28.5 inches
- Weight
- 434 pounds
View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Affiliate link
The Signature Hardware Lena is a 72-inch clawfoot soaking tub made from cast iron. It measures 30.5 inches wide and 28.5 inches high. The center drain placement and pre-drilled overflow hole simplify installation. You get a classic look with white enamel and brushed nickel feet. This heavy tub offers a calm bathing experience.
Pros
- Cast iron construction for durability
- 72-inch length for deep soaking
- Center drain placement
- 25-year limited warranty coverage
Cons
- 434-pound weight requires strong floor support
- No handheld shower or faucet included
- Limited to standard clawfoot installation
Good fit if
- You want a classic clawfoot style
- You need a deep soaking tub
- You prefer durable cast iron material
Skip if
- You have a weak floor structure
- You want a modern alcove design
- You need a lightweight acrylic tub
Verdict: Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Tub suits buyers seeking a heavy, durable soaking tub with a traditional aesthetic. It fits bathrooms with strong floors and classic decor.
Vintage Tub & Bath 72" Acrylic Clawfoot
Best for: Classic style and two-person soaking
- Type
- Double Slipper Clawfoot Tub
- Material
- Acrylic
- Length
- 72 inches
- Color
- White
- Dimensions
- 72 × 31 × 32 inches
- Weight
- 79 pounds
View on Amazon: Vintage Tub & Bath 72" Acrylic Clawfoot Affiliate link
The Vintage Tub & Bath Serenity is a 72-inch double slipper clawfoot tub made from high-gloss acrylic. It measures 31 inches wide and 32 inches tall, weighing 79 pounds. The non-porous surface resists mold, mildew, and fading. Adjustable lion paw feet stabilize the unit after installation. This lightweight design simplifies setup while offering a spacious soak for two.
Pros
- 72-inch length provides ample soaking space
- High-gloss acrylic resists stains and fading
- Non-porous surface prevents mold and mildew
- Adjustable feet ensure stable leveling
Cons
- Feet ship unattached and require assembly
- Custom painted versions are non-returnable
- 79-pound weight may require floor support check
Good fit if
- You want a classic clawfoot aesthetic
- You need a tub for two people
- You prefer easy-to-clean non-porous surfaces
Skip if
- You need a pre-assembled unit
- You have a small bathroom under 72 inches
- You prefer drop-in installation styles
Verdict: Vintage Tub & Bath Serenity 72" Acrylic Clawfoot is a spacious, durable option for bathrooms that can accommodate its 72-inch length. It fits you best if you prioritize classic style and easy maintenance over pre-installed convenience.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron | Vintage Tub & Bath 72" Acrylic Clawfoot |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Clawfoot | Double Slipper Clawfoot Tub |
| Material | Cast iron | Acrylic |
| Length | 72 inches | 72 inches |
| Drain Location | Center | not stated |
| Color | White / Brushed Nickel Feet | White |
| Mount Type | Clawfoot | Clawfoot |
| Dimensions | 72 × 30.5 × 28.5 inches | 72 × 31 × 32 inches |
| Weight | 434 pounds | 79 pounds |
| Model | 917203-72-RR | RMA72DS7WLPMB |
Frequently asked questions
Which brand makes a lighter bathtub for easier installation?
Vintage Tub & Bath offers a significantly lighter option. Their 72-inch acrylic clawfoot model weighs only 79 pounds. This makes it much easier to move and position than the Signature Hardware alternative, which weighs 434 pounds due to its cast iron construction. You will need less structural support for the lighter tub.
Does Signature Hardware offer a tub suitable for deep soaking?
Yes, the Signature Hardware Lena is designed for classic bathrooms needing deep soaking. It is a 72-inch cast iron clawfoot tub with a width of 30.5 inches. The heavy cast iron material provides durability and helps retain heat, allowing for longer, warmer soaks compared to thinner materials.
What is the difference in height between these two clawfoot tubs?
The Vintage Tub & Bath model stands taller at 32 inches high. The Signature Hardware Lena is slightly shorter, measuring 28.5 inches in height. Both tubs share the same 72-inch length, but the height difference may affect how easily you can enter and exit each model.
Which bathtub is better for supporting two people?
The Vintage Tub & Bath 72-inch acrylic clawfoot is noted for being spacious and suitable for two-person soaking. Its width of 31 inches provides ample room. The Signature Hardware model is also 72 inches long but is generally recommended for buyers seeking a traditional, durable soaking experience rather than maximum capacity.
Do these tubs come with pre-installed feet?
The Signature Hardware Lena features brushed nickel feet as part of its standard design. The Vintage Tub & Bath model is described as a clawfoot tub, which implies it includes feet, though specific finish details are not listed in the provided data. Both are designed for floor-standing installation.
Which material holds heat better during a bath?
Cast iron, used by Signature Hardware, is known for superior heat retention. The Lena tub’s heavy construction keeps water warm longer than acrylic. Vintage Tub & Bath uses acrylic, which is durable and easy to maintain but does not retain heat as effectively as the heavy cast iron option.
Are both brands offering white color options?
Yes, both brands provide white color options for their 72-inch clawfoot tubs. The Vintage Tub & Bath model is listed specifically as white. The Signature Hardware Lena is available in white with brushed nickel feet. You can choose based on your preferred foot finish and material texture.