Looking Beyond the Signature Hardware 312540 Lena 72" Cast? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look

How these tubs differ

Vintage Tub Charlotte 72" Cast Iron Slipper

The Vintage Tub Charlotte 72" Cast Iron Slipper is significantly heavier than the Signature Hardware Lena, weighing 538 pounds compared to 434 pounds. It shares the same 72-inch length and cast iron material but stands slightly taller at 30 inches versus 28.5 inches. This increased height may affect accessibility for some users. The slipper design offers a deeper soak on one end, which changes the bathing experience from the Lena’s uniform depth. You should choose this model if you want a classic look with a more pronounced soaking area, provided your floor can support the extra weight. The chrome feet and fixtures offer a different aesthetic than the brushed nickel options available on the Lena.

Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron

The Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron provides a shorter footprint for smaller bathrooms. It measures 59 inches long, saving 13 inches of space compared to the 72-inch original. It is also lighter, weighing 356 pounds against the Lena 72’s 434 pounds, making installation easier in structures with weight limits. The width is narrower at 17.7 inches, which reduces the overall bulk in tight spaces. However, this reduced length means less soaking capacity for taller users. If you prioritize classic clawfoot style and durability but have limited floor space, this 59-inch model is a practical alternative. It retains the same cast iron construction and quality standards as the larger version.

Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Clawfoot

The Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Clawfoot sits between the 59-inch and 72-inch models in size. It is 67 inches long, offering 5 inches less length than the original while remaining lighter at 390 pounds. The width is also reduced to 27.9 inches, making it more compact than the 30.5-inch original. This model suits bathrooms where a full 72-inch tub is too large but a 59-inch tub feels too small. It maintains the durable cast iron construction and classic clawfoot aesthetic you expect from the Lena series. If you need a mid-size option that balances soaking space with manageable weight and dimensions, this 67-inch variant is a solid choice.

Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Tub

The Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Tub in Slate Blue offers the same 72-inch length and similar weight of 411 pounds as the white original. The primary difference is the color and foot finish. This model features a slate blue interior with oil-rubbed bronze feet, providing a distinct visual contrast to the standard white and brushed nickel combination. The width is slightly narrower at 18.8 inches, which may affect the perceived spaciousness of the soak. If you want the durability and classic shape of the Lena 72 but prefer a darker, more dramatic color scheme, this variant allows you to customize the bathroom’s aesthetic without changing the tub’s functional specifications.

Vintage Tub & Bath 72" Acrylic Clawfoot

The Vintage Tub & Bath 72" Acrylic Clawfoot is dramatically lighter than the cast iron Lena, weighing only 79 pounds compared to 434 pounds. This makes it much easier to install and suitable for floors with lower weight-bearing capacity. It is also taller at 32 inches, offering a deeper water line than the 28.5-inch Lena. The acrylic material heats up faster than cast iron but may not retain heat as long. The double slipper shape provides comfort on both ends, differing from the Lena’s standard soaking profile. Choose this model if you want a lightweight, easy-to-install tub with a modern acrylic finish and a double-ended design, rather than the traditional heavy cast iron build.

Vintage Tub & Bath Serenity 72" Acrylic

The Vintage Tub & Bath Serenity 72" Acrylic shares the same lightweight profile as the other acrylic option, weighing just 79 pounds. It matches the Lena 72 in length but stands taller at 32 inches. The acrylic construction offers a smooth, easy-to-clean surface that is less prone to chipping than cast iron enamel. However, it does not provide the same thermal mass or classic clawfoot aesthetic as the Signature Hardware model. The white finish is standard and versatile. This tub is ideal for renters or homes where structural reinforcement for heavy cast iron is not feasible. It provides a similar soaking length with significantly reduced installation complexity and floor load requirements.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron

Best for: Classic clawfoot soaking tubs

Type

Clawfoot

Material

Cast iron

Length

72 inches

Drain Location

Center

Dimensions

72 × 30.5 × 28.5 inches

Weight

434 pounds

View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron

The Signature Hardware Lena 72 is a cast iron clawfoot soaking tub measuring 72 inches long, 30.5 inches wide, and 28.5 inches high. It weighs 434 pounds and features a center drain. This heavy-duty tub suits you if you want a classic clawfoot style with a durable enamel finish. It includes a pre-drilled overflow hole and comes with a 25-year limited warranty.

Pros

• Cast iron construction for durability
• 72-inch length for soaking
• Center drain placement
• 25-year limited warranty

Cons

• Extremely heavy at 434 pounds
• No adjustable depth settings
• Fixed clawfoot configuration

Good fit if

• You want a classic clawfoot design
• You need a 72-inch soaking tub
• You prefer durable cast iron material

Skip if

• You cannot support a 434-pound tub
• You need a lighter acrylic option
• You want a built-in or alcove tub

Verdict: Signature Hardware Lena 72 Cast Iron is a sturdy, classic soaking tub for those who value durability and traditional clawfoot aesthetics. It fits well in spacious bathrooms where you can accommodate its significant weight and fixed dimensions.

2 Best budget

Vintage Tub Charlotte 72" Cast Iron Slipper

Best for: Durable soaking in standard-sized bathrooms

Type

Clawfoot

Material

Cast iron

Length

72

Dimensions

72 × 30 × 30 inches

Weight

538 pounds

View on Amazon: Vintage Tub Charlotte 72" Cast Iron Slipper

This 72-inch slipper clawfoot tub from Vintage Tub & Bath is built from class A porcelain enamel over cast iron. It measures 30 inches wide and 30 inches high. The heavy 538-pound weight ensures stability and superior heat retention. This model offers a timeless design suitable for bathrooms needing a durable, spacious soaking option.

Pros

• 72-inch length provides ample soaking space
• Cast iron construction ensures high durability
• Porcelain enamel finish resists chipping and staining
• 30-inch width accommodates larger bodies comfortably

Cons

• 538-pound weight requires reinforced floor support
• Slipper design limits full recline compared to double slipper models
• Chrome fixtures may require separate maintenance

Good fit if

• You need a standard 72-inch tub for a spacious bathroom
• You prioritize heat retention and long-term durability
• You want a classic clawfoot aesthetic with chrome accents

Skip if

• You have a floor with limited weight capacity
• You prefer a double slipper design for full reclining
• You want a lighter acrylic material for easier installation

Verdict: Vintage Tub Charlotte 72" Cast Iron Slipper fits buyers who value heavy-duty construction and classic styling over lightweight convenience. It is ideal for those with strong flooring who want a tub that retains heat effectively.

3 Also great

Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron

Best for: compact bathrooms needing classic style

Type

Clawfoot soaking tub

Material

Cast iron

Length

59 inches

Drain Location

Center

Mount Type

clawfoot and free standing

Dimensions

59 × 17.7 × 26.8 inches

View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron

The Signature Hardware Lena 59-inch cast iron soaking tub offers a classic clawfoot design in a compact footprint. At 59 inches long and 17.7 inches wide, it fits smaller bathrooms better than standard 72-inch models. The heavy cast iron construction ensures durability, while the center drain placement provides a traditional look. You get a white finish with chrome feet and a 25-year limited warranty for long-term peace of mind.

Pros

• 59-inch length suits smaller spaces
• Durable cast iron construction
• Center drain placement
• 25-year limited warranty
• Classic clawfoot design

Cons

• Shorter 59-inch length limits soaking space
• Heavier 356-pound build requires strong flooring
• Standard 17.7-inch width may feel narrow

Good fit if

• You need a tub for a smaller bathroom
• You prefer a classic clawfoot aesthetic
• You want durable cast iron material

Skip if

• You require a deep soaking experience
• You have a 72-inch alcove space
• You prefer lightweight acrylic materials

Verdict: Signature Hardware Lena 59" Cast Iron is a practical choice for compact bathrooms where space is limited but classic style is desired. It fits buyers who prioritize durability and traditional clawfoot design over maximum soaking capacity.

4 Best premium

Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Clawfoot

Best for: Compact bathrooms needing durable cast iron

Type

clawfoot

Material

cast iron

Length

67 inches

Mount Type

free standing

Dimensions

67 × 27.9 × 27.9 inches

Weight

390 pounds

View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Lena 67" Cast Iron Clawfoot

The Signature Hardware 946168 Lena is a 67-inch cast iron clawfoot tub designed for free-standing installation. It measures 27.9 inches in width and height, offering a compact footprint for smaller bathrooms. The rolled rim adds a classic touch. You will appreciate the durable construction and the 25-year limited warranty. This model is ideal for those seeking a traditional soaking experience without the bulk of larger 72-inch alternatives.

Pros

• Cast iron material ensures long-term durability
• 25-year limited warranty for residential use
• Free-standing clawfoot design fits various layouts
• Rolled rim provides a classic aesthetic

Cons

• Smaller 67-inch length compared to 72-inch competitors
• Heavier 390-pound build requires strong flooring
• Drain is not included with the tub

Good fit if

• You need a tub that fits a smaller bathroom space
• You prefer the durability of cast iron over acrylic
• You want a traditional clawfoot style with a rolled rim

Skip if

• You require a 72-inch length for maximum soaking space
• You cannot support a 390-pound weight on your floor
• You prefer an acrylic tub for easier installation

Verdict: Signature Hardware 67" Lena Cast Iron Tub is a sturdy option for bathrooms where space is limited. It suits buyers who value the longevity of cast iron and do not need the extra length of a 72-inch model.

5 Also great

Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Tub

Best for: Traditional bathrooms with reinforced floors

Type

Clawfoot soaking tub

Material

Cast iron

Length

72 inches

Drain Location

Center

Mount Type

clawfoot and free standing

Dimensions

72 × 18.8 × 28.5 inches

View on Amazon: Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Tub

This 72-inch clawfoot soaking tub is built from cast iron for lasting durability. It stands 28.5 inches high and weighs 411 pounds, requiring a strong floor. The center drain placement simplifies plumbing connections. You get a classic aesthetic with a slate blue finish and oil-rubbed bronze feet. It fits well in spaces where you want a traditional, heavy-duty soaking experience.

Pros

• Cast iron construction ensures long-term durability
• 72-inch length provides ample soaking space
• Center drain placement simplifies installation
• 25-year limited warranty covers defects
• Available in multiple foot finish options

Cons

• 411-pound weight demands reinforced flooring
• 28.5-inch height may be difficult to enter
• No handheld showerhead included in the package

Good fit if

• You need a 72-inch tub for deep soaking
• You prefer the classic look of clawfoot designs
• You want a center drain for easier plumbing

Skip if

• Your floor cannot support over 400 pounds
• You prefer a lightweight acrylic material
• You need a tub with a built-in handheld sprayer

Verdict: Signature Hardware Lena 72" Cast Iron Tub offers a durable, classic soaking experience for those with the structural support for its heavy cast iron build. It is ideal for traditional bathrooms where plumbing simplicity and long-term material integrity matter most.

6 Also great

Vintage Tub & Bath 72" Acrylic Clawfoot

Best for: lightweight double slipper soaking

Type

Double Slipper Clawfoot Tub

Material

Acrylic

Length

72 inches

Color

White

Dimensions

72 × 31 × 32 inches

Weight

79 pounds

View on Amazon: Vintage Tub & Bath 72" Acrylic Clawfoot

The Vintage Tub & Bath Serenity is a 72-inch double slipper clawfoot tub made from high-gloss acrylic. It weighs 79 pounds, which is significantly lighter than the cast iron options on this list. The non-porous surface resists mold and mildew. Adjustable lion paw feet stabilize the unit. This lightweight design simplifies installation for you.

Pros

• 72-inch double slipper shape offers ample soaking space
• Acrylic material weighs only 79 pounds
• Non-porous surface resists mold and mildew buildup
• Adjustable levelers stabilize the tub on uneven floors

Cons

• Acrylic construction is less durable than cast iron
• Feet ship unattached and require assembly
• Custom painted versions are non-returnable

Good fit if

• You need a tub that is easy to move into place
• You want a double slipper shape for two people
• You prefer a lightweight material for floor support

Skip if

• You require the heavy, heat-retaining feel of cast iron
• You want a pre-assembled unit with no installation work
• You are buying a custom color and cannot accept return restrictions

Verdict: Vintage Tub & Bath Serenity 72" Acrylic fits you if you prioritize easy installation and a double slipper shape over the weight and heat retention of cast iron.

7 Also great

Vintage Tub & Bath Serenity 72" Acrylic

Best for: Lightweight soaking tub installation

Type

Double Slipper Clawfoot Tub

Material

High-gloss, stain-resistant acrylic

Length

72 inches

Mount Type

freestanding

Color

White

Dimensions

72 × 31 × 32 inches

View on Amazon: Vintage Tub & Bath Serenity 72" Acrylic

This is a 72-inch double slipper clawfoot tub made from high-gloss acrylic. It weighs only 79 pounds, which is much lighter than the cast iron options on this list. The non-porous surface resists mold and mildew. It features adjustable levelers on the lion paw feet for stability. This tub suits you if you want a soaking tub that is easier to install and maintain than heavier cast iron models.

Pros

• Lightweight 79-pound acrylic construction
• Non-porous surface resists mold and mildew
• High-gloss finish resists scratching and fading
• Adjustable levelers stabilize the tub

Cons

• Acrylic material is less durable than cast iron
• Feet ship unattached and require assembly
• Custom painted colors are non-returnable

Good fit if

• You need a lighter tub for upper-floor installation
• You prefer a non-porous surface for easy cleaning
• You want a double slipper design for soaking

Skip if

• You prefer the heavy, traditional feel of cast iron
• You want a tub that arrives fully assembled
• You need a custom color with easy returns

Verdict: Vintage Tub & Bath Serenity 72" Acrylic Tub is a practical choice for those prioritizing lightweight installation and low maintenance over the permanence of cast iron.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions